Not Conscious? If you don’t mind, I’d just like to borrow an organ or two…

In the 2005 film, The Island, conscious clones are harvested for their organs. In the middle of the film, we learn that Dr. Merrick, the mastermind behind the operation, is lying to the public, claiming that the clones never obtain consciousness.

There are logical reasons why he would make such a claim. Without consciousness, none of us would ever have the experiences and created individualities that make us all unique. Consciousness is the basis of how we distinguish ourselves from other species, and in many ways, it is what makes us “human.” If the public was to understand that Dr. Merrick’s clones were alive, there would be no end to the public’s unease with organ harvesting from “human” clones. Then again, there are those individuals who will do anything to survive. Lincoln’s sponsor Tom Lincoln, who claims to want to help Lincoln,  turns on his clone, saying that he apologizes, but he wants to live.

In class, we have been asked: “Would you take organs from a clone?” For me, it would depend on the context. If the clones never obtain consciousness, as the public is told in The Island, I would say yes, the same way I would say yes to abortions, if the fetuses have not obtained consciousness. After all, what have these beings lost? They do not experience pain, sadness, or loss. Without thoughts and understanding, they have not knowingly missed anything. And if you believe in a just God of some sort, I doubt fetuse’s/clone’s soul would be unfairly sent to suffer in eternal fire. Another argument may be that the mothers of aborted fetuses will be affected by the deaths of their fetuses. Unconscious clones will not have known have grown relationships with others, and thus this would not be a problem. The death of conscious clones who have had real human relations will be seen as a loss to others.

 If clones are conscious, here’s nothing distinguishes me from a clone in terms of “humanness,” if we both have experiences and knowingly are our own unique beings. The only thing differing between us would be that for the clone, there would be another individual with identical physical features, which in no way has anything to do with our uniqueness as individuals in terms of thoughts, beliefs, and personalities, which in our society of today, we believe should be more valued than physical attributes.

Thus, if the clones and I are equally human, what I am really being asked is: “Would I be willing to take the life of another human being to survive?” This question has been asked in dozens of modern films of today, from the Saw series to Alive. In Saw, individuals are promised their own survival if they are able to kill the others in the most brutal of ways; Alive is based on a true story of survival cannibalism, where survivors of a plane crash resort to eating one another while stranded in the Andes mountains. This concept is pictured less horrendously in The Island when Tom and Lincoln make their final desperate pleas for survival, by trying to prove themselves to be the real Tom Lincoln to the mercenary sent to extinguish the clone.  

If I were ever placed in every-man-for-himself circumstances, I’d like to think that my human morals and values would keep me mentally strong enough to resist the animalistic instincts to want to survive.  But I honestly don’t know what I’d do if something like that ever occurred.  Let’s just hope that we’ll never be stranded on an abandoned island together, because in all the chaos, I could very well be that person gnawing on your elbows.



~ by djoe8 on February 14, 2010.

One Response to “Not Conscious? If you don’t mind, I’d just like to borrow an organ or two…”

  1. Here’s a question that came to mind when I read your post: do you think the cause of the imminent death affects a person’s reaction to the threat?

    For some reason I imagine that if I was lying in a hospital bed it would be easier for me to accept the possibility of death, compared to if someone was holding a gun to my head, at which point I would most certainly panic. In both cases, I am at risk of dying. It shouldn’t matter how. And while I can’t say for certain what my reactions would be – I’m not saying in either case that I would just lay down and die – I really think I might treat death differently depending on the scenario.

    Never Let Me Go and The Island are both dealing with the issue of clones being raised for organs. But Never Let Me Go is very different from The Island because the characters of Never Let Me Go have time – they can contemplate their death and work through their emotions, and they even accept their fates. The Island, instead, is a frantic race to survive pushed by this adrenaline of a sudden, horrific discovery.

    I found your post really interesting (and chilling), but I wondered if you found the differences between Never Let Me Go and The Island applicable here. Is there more to the question than “Would I be willing to take the life of another human being to survive?”

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: